WARNING-
--CRITIQUE INCOMING--
Clone Trooper (Rifleman)
-I think this looks perfect so far.
Clone Support Trooper
-I think he looks good in the images.
Clone Paratrooper
-Looks just like in the movie.
Clone Shadow Trooper
-He looks good, not original but better than usual. How about some shine to him?
Bail Organa
-Texture on the head is stretched and weird in a creepy way. Fix that. Gun is wonderful.
Assault Droid
-Try making him grey in general, but camo for every map. It is more interesting, original, and mature that the cartoon's tan coloring everywhere. Other than that, looking forward to him.
Assassin Droid
-Grey again, but with camo even more extensively, please (consistency and realism). Hope his gun has an accurate sound effect, and the sound doesn't carry too far.
SBD
-Good job. Maybe shinier, with more RC sounds including voice sounds. Also, I would experiment with camo for him too, but probably leave him as is. The SBD's were meant to be terrifying and not really camouflaged.
IG-100 Assassin
-Love the concept, but wish for once the effect wasn't just a loss of opacity. I want to see that watery effect like on the stock bothan spy. Also, regular camo helps too.
IG Lancer Assassin
-Love concept too, and think it looks professional.
B2-RP
-Like it. Love the blending of the skinning and specular on the droid and jetpack. Must have RC sounds like SBD if you change SBD.
Confederate Commando
-Like it too, but fix the skin. First off, strange blue-green tint is unnecessary to the bulk of the body. Second, fix the face skin. Finally, make it less obvious it's a stormtrooper suit, perhaps reskin the suit a bit. Love the gun. Would love to see the random appearence thing going on here.
BX Commando Droid
-Like how you include it to balance overpowered Republic sides, but looks too cartoony. Reskin, give some specular, if feeling adventurous, remodel it too. All for a more realistic look. Camo would be interesting here.
IG-100 Magna Guard
-Hope his electrostaff sounds like an electrostaff, and not like a lightsaber. Bonus Eaol Points if you give him new voice sounds, and love the damage effect from it with the purple lightning.
Cad Baine
-Not a common CIS player, but love the inclusion, as he actually looks good here. Don't get too sloppy on the skin though, with all the realism here, don't use the cartoon for ALL your reference. Look for an image of a duros' face.
Rebel Soldier
-Perfect. Would also love to see the random appearence thing going on here.
Rebel Bombardier
-Name could change at your will. Like his appearence, but don't get too close to always looking like Kota's militia. I think his helmet is too crisp and clean compared to his body.
Bothan Field Medic
-Like. Bit too bloody, Get some of it off, not too realistic, and the handprint bothers me, not because it's bloody, but for its size.
Aqualish Engineer
-Like. The skin is surprising for a scratch-built one. Somehow fits on stock model well. If you do wish to enhance it, I really don't have a good image. Should have flipper-looking things for hands but whatever floats your boat.
Sullustan Sergeant
-One thing that always bothers me is when you assign a rank to a class. Like all sergeants are Sullastan, or all sergeants wear white. Like it though. Enhance detail on the skin though, and give camouflage.
Twi'lek Officer
-Sexy. Not original, but love it. Love to see random unit thing go on here too. Camo and moderate armor works too.
Bothan Spy
-Familiar...must be my imagination. Don't forget his watery effect for the invisibility.
Twi'lek Saboteur
-Perfect, but please don't make her sprint at 46 MPH. It's rediculously unrealistic, and silly. The standard BF2 speed is pushing it already.
Rebel Jet Trooper
-Like. Hope that's a shotgun. If so, give it a new sound and blast effect. We need variation. If possible, have it resemble the SWBF: Elite Squadron shotgun sound. Maybe even find a similar jetpack sound. It's in the first Mandalore Clone Wars episode from Season 2.
Rebel Skytrooper
-Love how you used unused concept art for a new unit. Inspires me greatly. Camo to match the air and ground needed.
Duros Smuggler
-Fix the face and use part of it on your Cad Baine.
Wookiee
-Make the wookiee powder-sugared in the snowy places.
SpecForce Urban Guerrilla
-Like. Hope he has a new voice though. Fix the face once again.
Katarn Trooper
-Like, but use reference and remove the blaster hole from chest. It's ugly and seems like he should be dead.
Mara Jade
-Creepy looking. Add some new hair, with transparency and cloth mechanics.
Stormtrooper
-Original. Like.
Stormtrooper Sergeant
-Like. Nothing to change here.
Imperial Officer
-Like. Remove the blue tint from the uniform though. It was a side-effect of looking at the special editions, like the blue Death Star and the pink-purple X-Wing engines and the blue TIEs.
Shadow Stormtrooper
-Like, but I think he needs a bit of shine too. For more realism.
Phase 2 Dark Trooper
-New voice? Like SBD? And I am hoping he's a bit taller than average soldier. Also, glad you didn't give him an X-Wing cannon XD
Glory-Class Dark Trooper
-LOVE THIS! Best looking unit I've seen so far from you. Nothing to fix here.
Radiation Trooper
-Nothing much, but I get annoyed by flashy effects. But it's yours, just stating an opinion. You can disregard this.
Jump Trooper
-Perfect.
Imperial Commando
-I'm bothered by his lack of armor. For a commando. He looks like a regular Imperial Soldier.
Storm Commando
-Like. Nothing to fix here.
Royal Guard
-I'd be most worried about his head, it's detached from his body.
Bossk
-You used the good model. 'Nuff said.
Boba Fett
-Looks much higher-rez than the rest of the units. Looks like you stole him from Star Wars Battlefront II. (Did you? lol jk)
Dengar
-Wish his mouth was covered, may be interesting. Like anyway.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
EFFECTS (Optional)
Would love to see more accurate effects, if you're into it. I have reference images:
Bowcaster:
IDK:
Blaster Impacts:
Ion Cannons (whatever this is good for):
Proton Torpedoes:
Muzzle Cooling mechanism:
Lack of Cooling for Non-hand Weapons:
Realistic Space Explosions:
Engine Glows (IDK):
Would also like to see the battledroid's main color grey, like their vehicles and fighters and VIRTUALLY EVERY OTHER BATTLE DROID MODEL. But it would make sense for camouflage, so perhaps this coloring:
Coruscant/Urban- Grey
Naboo- Tan
Dagobah/Swamp- Tan/Green
Hoth/Rhen Var/Snowy- White/Grey
Geonosis- Tanish/Reddish
Kashyyyk/Jungle- Grey/Tan
Tantive/Interior Maps- Grey
Space- Grey and Blue/Red
Utapau- Tan
Tatooine/Desert- Tan
Bespin- Grey/Tan
Yavin 4/Rainforest- Tan/Green
Endor/Forest- Green/Grey
And whatever logically fits elsewhere.
Make sure Imperial vehicles lose the blue tint. It only exists because of the color-goofing of the Special Edition releases. The Death Star is grey, TIEs are grey, Vader's lightsaber is red, blue sabers are light-blue, etc.
Have a nice day!
P.S.- That was not sarcasm, just thought it may come off as such, that's why this page script is here.